How the War on Sex Ed Became an Anti-Abortion Battleground

“All this works in favor of the anti-abortion, anti-rights movement,” says Guttmacher‘s director of federal policy.

Danielle Han

In a video that’s been viewed over 100 million times on TikTok, Namibian teacher Gelda Waterboer sings to her first-grade students in the tune of a familiar nursery rhyme: “These are my private parts, private parts, private parts, these are my private parts.” Gesturing to her chest, crotch, and behind, she continues with gumption so passionate it sounds angry: “No one should touch them.”

Many of the video’s comments are encouraging. “Yes. Louder! Teaching kids to not be shy about this is so important,” one user says. Another, “This is actually the level of seriousness needed for this.” Others have criticized Waterboer for the video, saying elementary school is too early for students to learn such lessons. But in Namibia, where teaching young kids about their health and wellbeing is the norm, sex education can start as early as fourth grade. The U.S. could afford to take a note or two.

After Dobbs, bills to restrict sex education have become increasingly common. Less than halfway through 2024, legislators brought forward over 130 such laws, a record high since 2018. And Project 2025, Trump’s terrifyingly obvious checklist for governing (though he once claimed otherwise), defines any kind of basic sexual health education as “pornography“–and wants to make it illegal.

“Sex education works like building blocks,” Sara Flowers, vice-president of education and training at Planned Parenthood, told PBS in 2021, in defense of the curricula. In elementary school, she says, consent is used for simple concepts, such as asking for a peer’s lunchbox snack, or respecting if someone doesn’t want a hug. In middle school, it means talking about peer pressure, and defining a kid’s own boundaries. And in high school, she explains, “we talk about consent during sex.”

Among Americans, sex ed is a widely popular concept and plenty of research suggests its benefits go beyond preventing STIs and early pregnancies. But despite the benefits of carving out a definitive and comprehensive sex-ed policy, access remains poor in the U.S.–and political divides (as well as the GOP’s obsession with managing people’s bodies) have made everything worse.

Without any federal regulation, sex education exists on a wobbly framework, and lessons operate on a case-by-case, state-by-state basis. In some ways, this can be good. By funding programs like the Teen Pregnancy Prevention Program, for example, the federal government allows states to decide how they want to implement sex-ed classes. It “helps create this space where you can make sure that everything that’s provided on the ground is evidence-based and innovative,” explains Amy Friedrich-Karnik, director of federal policy of the Guttmacher Institute, to Jezebel. “It doesn’t have to be one size fits all.”

But consequently, U.S. sex ed looks like a patchwork of varying curricula, with some classrooms providing comprehensive sex education, some instructing abstinence, and worryingly, some starting to teach abstinence-until-pregnant-but!-wait!-if-you-get-pregnant-do!-not!-abort! (More on that below.)

Today, only 41 states and Washington, D.C. require sex education to be taught in schools, Kimya Forouzan, Guttmacher’s principal state-policy advisor, tells Jezebel. “It does go down further in terms of specifics to the local level of what a local school district is approving…but a lot of that is influenced by what is required at the state level.”

And even in states with comprehensive sex education, challenges are rampant. Sex-ed lessons are typically limited to one-off lessons in middle- or high-school, and curricula are often shoehorned into health, physical-education, and science lessons, usually taught by teachers who are improperly trained or unqualified to discuss the subject. Still, all this is better than abstinence-only programs–which are often cited for being inaccurate, ineffective, and even dangerous.

Currently, 14 states teach abstinence-only lessons, and many of them have rebranded the curricula as “sexual risk avoidance” programs. This sort of education, Forouzan explains, “stigmatiz[es] information that’s required around sexual orientation and gender identity, things of that nature.” And by sharing false and misleading information about reproductive health and sexuality, such lessons can also shut teens off from necessary–and sometimes life-saving–information. According to Guttmacher, the federal government spends up to $110 million per year on “adolescent pregnancy” programs, many of which encourage teens to practice abstinence until marriage.

And beyond abstinence-only education is an even greater evil; anti-abortion education. According to a report by Teen Vogue, fetal-development lessons are emerging as a new front in the sex-ed wars, with some states requiring students to watch ultrasounds and fetus simulations as part of their sex-ed courses. At the forefront of these policies has been one “educational” video, titled “Baby Olivia,” created by anti-abortion group Live Action. In the three-minute video, viewers are taken through the 38-week journey of Olivia, a freaky-ass fetus, whose “journey” includes saccharine British narration and trillingly tacky orchestral music. The video, which asserts life begins at conception and that Olivia begins “playing” at 11 weeks, the three-minute film finishes with a climactic crescendo and a monochrome-lettered call-to-action: “Share her story.”

Many medical professionals have condemned the Baby Olivia video, noting it is riddled with false information and misleading language. “Obviously the video is computer-generated and aims to personify the embryo and fetus, which seems to be developing in outer space,” one OB-GYN told Reckon in a statement. Another OB-GYN, from Nashville, said it portrayed “false embryology.” And in a statement to NPR, ACOG said that “like much anti-abortion misinformation, [it was] designed to manipulate the viewer rather than to share evidence-based, scientific information about embryonic and fetal development…Many of the claims made in this video are not aligned with scientific fact, but rather reflect the biased and ideological perspectives of the extremists who created the video.”

Such videos “purport to show fetal development from conception to birth,” Forouzan tells Jezebel, “but really they are intended to stigmatize abortion, put forth this idea of [fetal] personhood, and we’ve seen that type of legislation be introduced in a ton of states, as well as enacted in several states.” According to Guttmacher’s tracker, states like Arkansas, Iowa, Idaho, Indiana, and Kansas have already introduced or passed legislation to show the “Baby Olivia” video.

Still, Live Action’s fodder-filled film is just the tip of the iceberg. Alongside other anti-abortion organizations looking to fill the sex-ed vacuum and pipeline young people into their agenda (Heartbeat International, a group that operates a network of crisis pregnancy centers and target vulnerable individuals, sells a pro-life curriculum for educators on its website), other efforts have also been caught in the crossfire of diminishing comprehensive sex ed.

Though sex education, at its very core, is about sex, it also opens conversations that lead to how students and youth feel about issues like LGBTQ+ rights, gender equity, and trans-affirming care. And a vanguard of foul policies–particularly under the Trump Administration–is putting young openmindedness at risk.

On Thursday the White House announced it would terminate sex-education grants to California, accusing the state’s curricula of including “gender ideology content” and refusing to comply with its demands. In June, the Supreme Court sided with parents who’d objected to children’s books portraying LGBTQ+ characters–thus setting a precedent that parents can opt their kids out of such lessons. In July, a Florida appeals court ruled against a trans teacher, disallowing her from using her pronouns.

Friedrich-Karnik and Forouzan explained to Jezebel that while sex ed stands as its own thing, the fight for holistic learning is overall an intersectional battle. “All this works in favor of the anti-abortion, anti-rights movement,” explains Friedrich-Karnik.

“It definitely exists in a network,” Forouzan adds. “Something that we notice and that we talk about is that there are so many efforts to cut off access to reproductive and sexual healthcare generally, whether those are abortion bans, whether those are bans on gender-affirming care, whether that’s increased parental involvement for contraception or for abortion, all at the same time…It’s all within the same system of cutting off education for people and then also cutting off the resources they may need related to their reproductive or sexual health care.”

Complete Article HERE!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *